yeet.foodby Ashley Hindle

Just Eat ratings in Sheffield (S)

Can you trust them?

Independent analysis of Just Eat ratings. Not affiliated with Just Eat.

76%rated 5/5 by Just Eat
22%would be 5★ on a plain average
How these figures work
80+ 65-79 <65

    Highest Eat Scores in Sheffield (S)

    Ranked from 172,535 counted Just Eat ratings, snapshot 2026-10-07. How the Eat Score works.

    1. Food Paradise*Eat Score98
      Sheffield · S70 2NZKebab, Burgers · 74 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 5.0/5 · Rating gap 2.0
    2. Best Boy BagelsEat Score97.6
      Sheffield · S7 1FNBagels, American · 74 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 5.0/5 · Rating gap 2.4
    3. AnticoEat Score97
      Sheffield · S13 8SEPizza, Pasta · 68 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 3.0
    4. Just Good FoodEat Score96.9
      Sheffield · S81 7BLBreakfast, Café · 91 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 3.1
    5. Indian ChefEat Score95.1
      Sheffield · S25 2PPCurry, Indian · 130 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 4.9
    6. The Neighbourhoods ChefEat Score94.9
      Sheffield · S12 4WAItalian, Pizza · 115 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.8/5 · Rating gap 5.1
    7. Sunday Roasts @ Porky'sEat Score94.9
      Sheffield · S10 1EDRoast Dinners, British · 30 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 5.0/5 · Rating gap 5.1
    8. ZizzonaEat Score94.9
      Sheffield · S8 0SEPizza, Italian · 28 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 5.0/5 · Rating gap 5.1
    9. Barbot SandwichesEat Score94.8
      Sheffield · S61 4RJSandwiches, Breakfast · 66 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 5.2
    10. Tuck In CafeEat Score94.4
      Sheffield · S61 3QYBreakfast, Desserts · 110 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 5.6

    Most disagreed restaurants in Sheffield (S)

    The largest Rating gaps: |Just Eat rating × 20 − Eat Score|. Higher means greater disagreement between the methods. At least 15 counted ratings required. How Rating gap works.

    1. BurgaboyRating gap76.4
      S9 5ABJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.3/5 · Eat Score 23.6/100 · 109 counted ratings
    2. Woodhouse-pizza&kebabRating gap71.3
      S13 7JXJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.4/5 · Eat Score 28.7/100 · 41 counted ratings
    3. Rudi's Burgers - ChesterfieldRating gap69.5
      S40 1XLJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.3/5 · Eat Score 30.5/100 · 17 counted ratings
    4. Sabir's GrillRating gap67.9
      S2 4LWJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 32.1/100 · 19 counted ratings
    5. Greggs - Shfield 17 Medhal ScRating gap66.6
      S9 1EHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 33.4/100 · 69 counted ratings
    6. Domino's - ClowneRating gap66.2
      S43 4LLJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 33.8/100 · 55 counted ratings
    7. Moo LabRating gap66.0
      S80 1DXJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 34/100 · 70 counted ratings
    8. Yummy PlazaRating gap65.9
      S2 1GUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 34.1/100 · 64 counted ratings
    9. Popeye PizzaRating gap65.4
      S2 2EHJust Eat 4.75/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 29.6/100 · 78 counted ratings
    10. Domino's - Sheffield - Crystal PeaksRating gap65.4
      S20 7PJJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 34.6/100 · 31 counted ratings

    5 stars on Just Eat, but many 1–2★ ratings, in Sheffield (S)

    Takeaways Just Eat rates 5 out of 5 where more than 15% of at least 20 counted ratings are 1–2 stars. Largest 1–2★ share first. How this works.

    1. Burgaboy1–2★ ratings43%
      S9 5ABJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.3/5 · Eat Score 23.6/100 · 109 counted ratings
    2. Woodhouse-pizza&kebab1–2★ ratings39%
      S13 7JXJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.4/5 · Eat Score 28.7/100 · 41 counted ratings
    3. Yummy Plaza1–2★ ratings38%
      S2 1GUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 34.1/100 · 64 counted ratings
    4. Domino's - Clowne1–2★ ratings36%
      S43 4LLJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 33.8/100 · 55 counted ratings
    5. Greggs - Shfield 17 Medhal Sc1–2★ ratings36%
      S9 1EHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 33.4/100 · 69 counted ratings
    6. Domino's - Sheffield - Crystal Peaks1–2★ ratings35%
      S20 7PJJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 34.6/100 · 31 counted ratings
    7. Sweet Panda1–2★ ratings35%
      S6 4JDJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.4/5 · Eat Score 35.2/100 · 20 counted ratings
    8. Moo Lab1–2★ ratings34%
      S80 1DXJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 34/100 · 70 counted ratings
    9. Crustiz Pizza Hillsborough1–2★ ratings34%
      S6 4JQJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 34.8/100 · 136 counted ratings
    10. Greggs - Sheffield, 6 Fargate1–2★ ratings33%
      S1 2HEJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 36.1/100 · 51 counted ratings