yeet.foodby Ashley Hindle

Just Eat ratings in S2 (Sheffield)

Can you trust them?

Independent analysis of Just Eat ratings. Not affiliated with Just Eat.

70%rated 5/5 by Just Eat
18%would be 5★ on a plain average
How these figures work
80+ 65-79 <65

    Highest Eat Scores in S2 (Sheffield)

    Ranked from 11,066 counted Just Eat ratings, snapshot 2026-09-28. How the Eat Score works.

    1. Cup&Crumb CafeEat Score89.5
      Sheffield · S2 3PFBreakfast, Café · 46 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.9/5 · Rating gap 10.5
    2. Dial a Pizza & KebabEat Score86.5
      Sheffield · S2 1GQPizza, Kebab · 58 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.7/5 · Rating gap 13.5
    3. The Original India GardenEat Score85.2
      Sheffield · S2 4HTIndian, Curry · 169 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.6/5 · Rating gap 14.8
    4. Fanoush Falafel BarEat Score84.7
      Sheffield · S2 4LEMediterranean, Vegan · 39 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.8/5 · Rating gap 15.3
    5. NEW JUMBO NJ chinese TakeawayEat Score81.3
      Sheffield · S2 5HPChinese, Asian · 123 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.6/5 · Rating gap 18.7
    6. Manor Top Fish BarEat Score80.7
      Sheffield · S2 1GQFish & Chips, English · 573 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.5/5 · Rating gap 19.3
    7. Cafe Indus - HighfieldEat Score80.6
      Sheffield · S2 4NAIndian, Curry · 69 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.6/5 · Rating gap 19.4
    8. Surena Pizza SheffieldEat Score78.7
      Sheffield · S2 1FHItalian, Pizza · 80 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.5/5 · Rating gap 21.3
    9. The Pizza Joint HalalEat Score78.7
      Sheffield · S2 1FFPizza, Italian · 89 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.6/5 · Rating gap 21.3
    10. Pizza BarEat Score78
      Sheffield · S2 4LJPizza, Kebab · 112 counted ratings · Just Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.5/5 · Rating gap 22.0

    Most disagreed restaurants in S2 (Sheffield)

    The largest Rating gaps: |Just Eat rating × 20 − Eat Score|. Higher means greater disagreement between the methods. At least 15 counted ratings required. How Rating gap works.

    1. Sabir's GrillRating gap67.0
      S2 4LWJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 33/100 · 19 counted ratings
    2. Yummy PlazaRating gap65.7
      S2 1GUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 34.3/100 · 64 counted ratings
    3. Popeye PizzaRating gap65.0
      S2 2EHJust Eat 4.75/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 30/100 · 78 counted ratings
    4. Wawin Vegan Chinese (Sheffield)Rating gap63.0
      S2 4QUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.5/5 · Eat Score 37/100 · 15 counted ratings
    5. Pepe's Piri Piri - SheffieldRating gap62.5
      S2 4LHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 37.5/100 · 84 counted ratings
    6. Mr. PizzaRating gap60.0
      S2 3AFJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.7/5 · Eat Score 40/100 · 165 counted ratings
    7. Kebabish ExpressRating gap54.7
      S2 4LRJust Eat 4.5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 35.3/100 · 859 counted ratings
    8. Caprinos Pizza - SheffieldRating gap54.7
      S2 4AFJust Eat 4/5 · Expected rating 3.3/5 · Eat Score 25.3/100 · 86 counted ratings
    9. PHAT Buns - SheffieldRating gap53.9
      S2 4LEJust Eat 4.5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 36.1/100 · 240 counted ratings
    10. Greggs - Sheffield, U3 Parkway Central RPRating gap52.1
      S2 5AUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.8/5 · Eat Score 47.9/100 · 132 counted ratings

    5 stars on Just Eat, but many 1–2★ ratings, in S2 (Sheffield)

    Takeaways Just Eat rates 5 out of 5 where more than 15% of at least 20 counted ratings are 1–2 stars. Largest 1–2★ share first. How this works.

    1. Yummy Plaza1–2★ ratings38%
      S2 1GUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 34.3/100 · 64 counted ratings
    2. Pepe's Piri Piri - Sheffield1–2★ ratings31%
      S2 4LHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.6/5 · Eat Score 37.5/100 · 84 counted ratings
    3. Mr. Pizza1–2★ ratings28%
      S2 3AFJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.7/5 · Eat Score 40/100 · 165 counted ratings
    4. Greggs - Sheffield, U3 Parkway Central RP1–2★ ratings24%
      S2 5AUJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 3.8/5 · Eat Score 47.9/100 · 132 counted ratings
    5. Taste of China1–2★ ratings21%
      S2 3AHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.0/5 · Eat Score 55.1/100 · 273 counted ratings
    6. Best Pizza1–2★ ratings20%
      S2 1GJJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.1/5 · Eat Score 55.8/100 · 70 counted ratings
    7. Family Fish Bar1–2★ ratings19%
      S2 1FHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.2/5 · Eat Score 60.4/100 · 47 counted ratings
    8. Phat Ville - Sheffield1–2★ ratings19%
      S2 4LEJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.1/5 · Eat Score 58.3/100 · 27 counted ratings
    9. Mother Hubbard's - Sheffield1–2★ ratings18%
      S2 4LHJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.1/5 · Eat Score 59.1/100 · 356 counted ratings
    10. Noodle Inn - London Road1–2★ ratings17%
      S2 4LTJust Eat 5/5 · Expected rating 4.2/5 · Eat Score 63.4/100 · 63 counted ratings